On Loving to Hate

The other day a student asked if I intended to read Dan Brown’s The Lost Symbol. I took a moment to recall the opening of The Great Gatsby when Nick Carraway repeats his father’s advice to “reserve all judgments.”

Then I said, “No way.  Not a chance.”

I ought to reserve judgment—particularly of books I haven’t read and particularly with students who benefit from any reading—but, when it comes to Dan Brown, I can’t help having an opinion.  When I read The Da Vinci Code a few years ago, I hated it so much that I stopped reading with five pages to go.  I could have stopped on the fifth page but wanted to hate it from a position of strength.  I needed a way to express my contempt more vividly.

If you love Dan Brown, I sincerely apologize.

I think you should stop reading now.

As an English teacher, I see books as my business and generally celebrate anyone appreciating any book.  In the past, I’ve had colleagues who’ve rejected some of the novels we teach as second rate, but, for me, a book students like is a good book.  I keep my misgivings about The Lord of the Flies to myself.  I bite my lip when students praise Of Mice and Men because I assume they sense something I’m too jaded to see.  I’ve never wanted to be the sort of snob who thinks we should teach Crime and Punishment instead of The Joy Luck Club because everyone knows that anyone who has a brain recognizes that Dostoyevsky is the better writer.

I generally don’t like hating books.  Though I listen patiently and recognize every citizen’s right to complain, I barely tolerate students who want to tell me (usually over and over and over) how little they enjoy the book I assigned them.  The fault, I say inwardly, may be the reader’s and not the writer’s.  Every book, I tell myself, offers something redeeming for the person who searches for it.

So why single out poor Dan Brown?

My wife finds it odd that I can muster such hatred toward so innocuous a figure. It is a little like hating white bread. I find my hatred odd too.  I state reasons—the amateurish way characters discuss clues as they flee from gunfire bugs me, as do the barely differentiated characters discussing these clues… endlessly, in tediously informative baby-step bits.  I’ve taught eighth graders who write more engaging dialogue, and the telling-heavy, showing-short chapters always, always, always end in cheesy and/or clumsy cliffhangers.

None of these objections, however, account for my hatred.  I sometimes play literary activist and say it’s a crime better writers go unpublished.  That’s certainly true, but worse writers are published too.  It’s occurred to me that, though I don’t author accounts of century-old global religious conspiracies couched as thrillers, maybe my hatred is jealousy.

When people who love Dan Brown chide me for spoiling their fun, I do feel guilty.  What’s wrong with a little jigsaw solving—even if it is a puzzle of finite, identically shaped pieces?  My hatred is irrational, and, being a rational man, I know the cure.  I should buy The Lost Symbol, strap myself to a chair and read it, cover to cover.  While I’m at it, I’ll read Twilight and all those other novels everyone else talks about too.

But I can already feel a biological fireball gathering in my lizard brain.  Please, oh Lord, don’t ever let me meet Mr. Brown.  I’ll be nice, but I might have to keep my hand over my mouth to arrest the sneer overcoming me.

Which—I know, I know—is not my best expression.


Filed under Art, Dan Brown, Doubt, Envy, Essays, Fiction, High School Teaching, Laments, life, Opinion, Showing and Telling, Teaching, Thoughts, Writing

5 responses to “On Loving to Hate

  1. defpunk

    Not to worry, I hate him too. I hate the Rowling girl too or plaguing popular culture with Harry Potter, I don’t care if that was her initial aim or not. And I hate people who ‘love to read’ but read one crappy thriller after the next.

    And I remember that one time a student in my class asked our philosophy teacher if we could watch The Matrix in class “because it’s so philosophical”. I’m ashamed of my generation. =(

    On the other hand I’m nerdy to the extreme what concerns my reading. Oliver Sacks is one of my favourite ‘authors’. How bad is that, like.

    I like Oliver Sacks too. I don’t mind J. K. Rowling, though I don’t see why one author has to blot out everyone else. At least Dan Brown hasn’t accomplished that. Thanks for visiting. —D

  2. Well, you are not alone. I think the writing is dreck. Though what is worse, when I read the book years ago ( and no, did not buy it – it was a Bookcrossing book) I found it cheesy and dull, and told a friend that for sure a movie was going to be made from it, slam dunk. Of course having a controversial conspiracy theory that some unfortunates think are based in reality is a sure way to appeal to popular taste. But then no one ever mistook popular for good taste, eh? G

    Sometimes popular and good align, and I’m enough of an idealist to believe it might happen more often if editors thought more about art and less about sales. —D

  3. …and how do you feel about Mitch Albom….? 😛

    I guess you’re saying I shouldn’t become a fan? His titles scare me away, so I haven’t read anything. —D

    • You haven’t missed a thing. I have a friend who thinks M.A. is a wonderful philosopher. We avoid speaking about literature.

      I’ve met his fans too. It’s hard to know what to do when someone loves a writer you abhor. I don’t like to unseat anyone’s hero–but sometimes it’s tough to bite your tongue. —D

  4. Pingback: The Great Calabaza | A Drink With My Brother

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s